Revisiting Darwin's hypothesis: Does greater intraspecific variability increase species' ecological breadth?

Abstract

• Premise of the study: Darwin first proposed that species with larger ecological breadth have greater phenotypic variation. We tested this hypothesis by comparing intraspecific variation in specific leaf area (SLA) to species’ local elevational range and by assessing how external (abiotic) filters may influence observed differences in ecological breadth among species. Understanding the patterns of individual variation within and between populations will help evaluate differing hypotheses for structuring of communities and distribution of species.• Methods: We selected 21 species with varying elevational ranges and compared the coefficient of variation of SLA for each species against its local elevational range. We examined the influence of external filters on local trait composition by determining if intraspecific changes in SLA with elevation have the same direction and similar rates of change as the change in community mean SLA value.• Key results: In support of Darwin's hypothesis, we found a positive relationship between species’ coefficient of variation for SLA with species’ local elevational range. Intraspecific changes in SLA had the same sign, but generally lower magnitude than the community mean SLA.• Conclusions: The results indicate that wide‐ranging species are indeed characterized by greater intraspecific variation and that species’ phenotypes shift along environmental gradients in the same direction as the community phenotypes. However, across species, the rate of intraspecific trait change, reflecting plastic and/or adaptive changes across populations, is limited and prevents species from adjusting to environmental gradients as quickly as interspecific changes resulting from community assembly.

Local Knowledge Graph (Top 57 entities)

View in full graph →

Loading graph...

Related Works

Items connected by shared entities, co-authorship, citations, or semantic similarity.

Student Paper

Intraspecific variation of specific leaf area along an elevational gradient

201143 shared entities

Student Paper

The Changing Floral Color Landscape Across an Alpine Elevation Gradient

201639 shared entities

Student Paper

Plant community composition with respect to species richness along an altitudinal gradient in gunnison county, co

200932 shared entities

Document

Vegetation Appendix Materials for Vegetation and Wildlife Studies for the Mount Emmons Project

35 shared entities

Document

Homestake Mining Company Pitch Project Environmental Statement

27 shared entities

Dataset

Data from: Are leaf functional traits “invariant” with plant size, and what is “invariance” anyway?

201572% similar

Dataset

Data from: Evidence of local adaptation to fine- and coarse-grained environmental variability in Poa alpina in the Swiss Alps

201771% similar

Dataset

Does environmental heterogeneity drive functional trait variation? A test in montane and alpine meadows

202171% similar

Document

Shrubland Ecosystem Genetics And Biodiversity: Proceedings

54% similar

Cited By (110 times, 2 in Knowledge Commons)

Student Paper

Assessing Plant Community Assembly Along an Elevational Gradient: A Functional Niche Hypervolume Approach

2017

Student Paper

Competitive hierarchy or niche packing? An examination of the effects of competition on community.

2014

References (37)

37 references to works outside the Knowledge Commons